BMW M240i or M2: Comparing the Pros and Cons

Debates over choosing an M-Lite or a true M car have persisted since M Performance cars, affectionately called M-Lites, entered the market. With the impressive prowess of M Performance vehicles, the answer remains elusive. Notably, the BMW M240i and M2 shine, as the former outpaces many previous-generation M cars. So, which should you buy? We’ll explore their pros and cons to help you find the perfect fit.

The BMW M240i offers several advantages. Firstly, it’s a compact BMW coupe featuring a classic design, which is increasingly rare nowadays. It boasts a long hood, short rear deck, balanced dash-to-axle ratio, and a well-executed Hofmeister Kink. All of these contribute to its appealing proportions. While not as striking as its predecessor, it outshines most modern BMWs in aesthetics.

Additionally, the M240i is a swift-performance car. Its 3.0-litre “B58” inline-six turbocharged engine produces 382 hp and 369 lb-ft of torque. With the ability to hit 60 mph in just 4.1 seconds, it may not seem immensely powerful, but these Bavarian horses certainly pack a punch.

However, the M240i isn’t without its flaws. Like any car, it has drawbacks that might deter someone from choosing it over the BMW M2. For instance, it lacks a steering feel and isn’t as sharp as the true M2. Despite its speed and sleek design, the M240i’s steering resembles a video game and misses the mark on responsiveness. While the ride is comfortable on rougher roads, it doesn’t match the M2’s engagement level.

The BMW M2’s key strengths are apparent. Its S58 3.0-liter twin-turbo I6 engine, generating 453 horsepower and 406 lb-ft of torque, is just the start. According to the manufacturer, it can hit 0-60 mph in 3.9 seconds with the eight-speed automatic. Notably, the M2 offers a six-speed manual transmission, significantly enhancing excitement and driver engagement compared to the M240i.

While the BMW M2 excels in many ways, it does have some drawbacks. Starting with its appearance, the front grille differs from the M240i’s and is less favoured. It features horizontal slats and a boxier design than the standard 2 Series, deviating from BMW’s iconic vertical grille slats. This is likely the only visual flaw with the M2, but it’s worth noting. The M2’s lacklustre colour options, offering just Toronto Red and Zandvoort Blue, fall short of the visual appeal seen in previous M cars. More colours are expected, but not for at least another year.

Both are exceptional cars, offering speed, solid handling, attractive design, and a comfortable interior unless you’re exceptionally demanding. Choosing between them is like adjusting a sliding scale for power, comfort, handling, quietness, and value. As with any decision, both cars have pros and cons, and buyers will select based on their preferences. So, keep these advantages and disadvantages in mind when making your choice.