Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

Markus

Well-Known Member
I hope that my post will serve to alert as many of you of what could potentially happen when you are unfortunate enough to have to make a motor accident insurance claim:

Day 1
- crash into back of lorry on Birthday :wtf:
- bonnet crumpled and front Hamann body kit fractured in middle - heng none of lights not shattered or radiator damage but bonnet cannot be opened
- call up AXA insurance; helpful CSO says policy only allows for approved workshop (note to self: if you are spending 2k (max NCB) on a policy, pay $100 more for unlimited workshop)
- look through list of approved workshop; pick only one that sounds familiar - STAR AUTO!? :errmm:
- drive to STAR Auto - impressed with one stop service - can file insurance report at same time
- take cab to restaurant for champagne lunch to get over misery :verysad:
- board flight to India somehwat drunk

Day 5
- back in Singapore
- call up STAR for update - helpful CSO says 2 weeks to repair car so lan lan hire pokey Polo
- enquire if possible to top up and have Hamann bodykit instead of STOCK
- STAR saleslady emails back in evening to say can but must top up $1.68k as insurance only cover for STOCK bodykit so reply let me consider but meantime please proceed with bonnet and whatever else needs to be done.

Day 6
- go down to STAR; have word with CSO and workshop supevisor. Enquire if M-tech would be cheaper than Hamann. Workshop promises to get back to me same day. Also ask for list of repairs. Nothing heard

Day 11
- send email reminder for response on bodykit. CSO says oops sorry for delay in replying but M-tech must top up $1.3k. Instruct CSO by email to forget about M-tech or Hamann and just proceed with STOCK. CSO reminded to get back to me asap on expected date of collection as leaving for Taipei.

Day 14
- email to CSO; hullo my car's estimated date of collection :huhhuh:

Day 16
- get PA to call as away in Taipei - efficient PA gets back within 15mins says workshop mgr say can collect tomolo Saturday last collection time
- arrange for brother to collect car as only arrive back after collection time

Day 17
- Brother drive car over. Gasp in shock - Car dirty inside and out; Bonnet gap on one side and protrude out on other by 5mm.....Hamann BODYKIT???? :wtf:
- write angry email to insurance company and STAR

Day 18
- email response from STAR workshop mgr to say will look into matter; 15 mins later workshop calls says um when are you coming down to pay the $1.6k ah? Blasted caller who then says okie nvm then.
- no response from AXA

Day 19
- workshop mgr calls and says sorry saw your email about Stock bodykit. But we fixed Hamann because we wanted to save you money as you would have had to replace your foglights with stock bodykit. Oh and we only use genuine stuff hor. Moreover we knew you were in Taipei so wanted to save you on phonebills. And regarding poor fit, how come your brother didnt' say anything during collection ah? If you like I can even come and drive your car down now to see what is wrong. Replied thanks for the bedtime story but I have no kids and I'd be crazy for you to touch my car. Regarding my brother, if you wanna go down that path how come you believed that he is my brother simply because some lady called claiming to be my PA ah? You oso never call to verify with me and simply release my car? :nutkick: . 30 mins later workshop mgr writes email to say sorry that we cannot live up to your expectations
- no response from AXA

Day 23
- AXA replies - wow at last! "Investigation reveals that STAR installed a STOCK bodykit for you and if you like they have pictures for you. Oh and you have a 9 month warranty for defects so you can always go and let them correct fault for you lor. Thank you and have a good day!". Send nasty email to AXA and STAR :biggun:

Day 25 (today)
- AXA replies - we are still looking into matter
- STAR workshop mgr responds to email - "we refute Marcus' claims that we are liars. We did fix a Hamann kit and we also have pictures if he would like to see them. On the bonnet and dirty car, how come his brother never indicate any fault when he collects. Yet I give Marcus benefit of doubt and offer him all the options but he has not accepted them so that we can make his experience with us a "Memorable" one. He can complaint (sic) to CASE if he wants. Oh and we here at STAR never never ever tell lies!!! Sompah! :stop!:

:bullshit: :bullshit: :bullshit:
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

sorry to hear about this Markus.
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

Sorry to hear about your experience, hope your case is resolved soon.

Star auto is under ST too? But not the same as ST's Starblack workshop right?
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

Thanks Motorknut and Dan for sharing in my angst.

Unfortunately they are both the same workshop. That is how I thought that I should go there in the first place....
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

Hope your matter gets resolved my friend. Such a sad case that the majority workshops in Singapore cannot simply just run an honest business.
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

Star Auto and Star Black are the same? Well looks like they never learn from that "Porsche Incident"
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

Markus;484928 said:
Thanks Motorknut and Dan for sharing in my angst.

Unfortunately they are both the same workshop. That is how I thought that I should go there in the first place....
Markus, sorry to hear this...damn sian to know these workshops are like that...their fancy advertisement is for show only...
Dan Ong;484930 said:
Star Auto and Star Black are the same? Well looks like they never learn from that "Porsche Incident"
what happened?
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

sorry 2 hear abt ur accident. glad u r ok. happy belated birthday!!!
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

wa, didn't know it was your birthday on the day it happened....

the service by both AXA and Star Auto is unacceptable. saw the Star Auto manager's email reply... that was just downright rude.
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

Thanks all for your support. Shy to say my birthday mah - lao liao :sickinbe:
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

I have forwarded your email to StarBlack's GM Pee Yap Aik. Orh Lulu will be meeting him tonight for wushu, so let him asked Pee on the details.
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

Thanks - hope Ah Orr dun kena chop by Ah Pee :nutkick:
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

markus sorry to hear about that but next time u should go to SWC... frm my experience its da best

they have the best service imho... no bullshit u want what bodykit after accident they can quote u right away... the estimation of the work done also zhun.. and they rent u a car while ur car is there...
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

what r the other approved workshops? possible to go to a more reputable one shld STAR fail to rectify?
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

Hmm...Orix leasing and a bunch of other ones I've never heard of in Sin Min. Too bad SWC, J4C, Yew Lip was not considered worthy...
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

maybe u might wanna consider paying a slight premium on ur insurance to have PML included as one of the approved workshops. if u need insurance company that includes PML let me know. i am under their coverage.
 
Re: Truly "memorable" Experience With Star Auto

Yeah Slater expensive lesson learnt. I will go with Sime Insurance next year.
 

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
82,747
Messages
1,019,309
Members
78,039
Latest member
pg88comim
Back
Top